In this article
- What's covered and what isn't
- Deductibles: the number that surprises people
- Replacement cost vs actual cash value
- The claims process, step by step
- Financing the gap
- Three things never to do
- Before the storm: three things to do now
- Roof age schedules and the newer policy forms
- How to read the adjuster's estimate
- Supplements, re-inspections and appraisal
- Working out the financing number
What's covered and what isn't
Standard policies cover sudden, accidental damage from named perils. For roofs that means hail, wind, falling objects, fire and the weight of ice or snow in most policies. They exclude gradual deterioration: an old roof that leaks because it's old is not a claim. The grey area is an older roof with storm damage; insurers may argue the damage is partly age, and some policies limit coverage on roofs past a certain age. Read the roof section of your policy before a storm, not after.
Deductibles: the number that surprises people
Many policies in hail and hurricane states now carry a separate wind/hail or hurricane deductible set as a percentage of the dwelling coverage, not a flat amount. On a home insured for a few hundred thousand dollars, a percentage deductible can run into thousands. That deductible is yours to pay, and a contractor who offers to waive it is proposing insurance fraud. Financing the deductible through a legitimate lender is the lawful route; see roof financing.
Replacement cost vs actual cash value
Replacement cost value (RCV) policies pay what it costs to replace the roof, usually in two parts: an initial payment less depreciation, then the recoverable depreciation once the work is done. Actual cash value (ACV) policies pay the depreciated value only, which on an old roof may be a fraction of the replacement cost. Some insurers have moved older roofs to ACV schedules. If you have an ACV roof, the gap you finance can be large.
The claims process, step by step
- Document immediately. Photos of the roof, gutters, siding, screens and any interior leaks. Date-stamped.
- Mitigate. Tarp active leaks; keep receipts. Policies require you to prevent further damage.
- Get a contractor inspection from a licensed roofer, ideally before the adjuster visits, so you have an independent scope.
- File the claim within your state's deadline. Deadlines vary by state and policy.
- Meet the adjuster. Have your roofer there if possible to walk the scope together.
- Compare scopes. If the adjuster's estimate is short, your roofer can submit a supplement with documentation.
- Get the first payment, do the work, then claim recoverable depreciation with the final invoice.
The scale is real: State Farm alone paid $5.6 billion in hail claims in 2025, with Texas at $1.4 billion (Claims Journal). After a major event, expect adjuster delays and book your roofer early.
Financing the gap
The gap is the deductible, any depreciation holdback you won't recover, upgrades the policy won't pay for (impact-resistant shingles, new decking beyond the allowance, gutters) and anything the adjuster declined. Most homeowners finance it with a personal loan or a contractor-arranged plan sized to the gap. Tell the lender the claim amount so the loan covers only what you need. Our six-option guide compares the routes.
Three things never to do
- Sign an assignment of benefits or contract on the roofer's first visit without reading it.
- Accept a "free roof" pitch or a waived deductible.
- Let the roof sit unrepaired while you argue; secondary water damage may not be covered if you didn't mitigate.
This article is general information, not legal or insurance advice. Policies and state rules differ; read yours and ask your insurer or an attorney about specifics.
Before the storm: three things to do now
- Photograph your roof and the soft metals (gutters, vents, AC fins) in good condition, with dates. "Before" photos make hail claims far easier.
- Find your roof's installation date and any warranty paperwork. Age drives both the payment schedule and the adjuster's view of pre-existing wear.
- Read the deductible line. If it's a percentage of dwelling coverage, calculate the dollar figure now so it isn't a surprise, and decide whether to keep an emergency fund or a financing plan ready for it.
Ten minutes of preparation can be the difference between a claim that pays the roof and one that pays a repair.
Roof age schedules and the newer policy forms
Insurers in storm-heavy states have been rewriting roof coverage. Three changes are now common, and they decide how much of a replacement you'll pay for yourself.
- Roof payment schedules. Some policies pay a percentage of replacement cost that falls with the roof's age, for example 100% for a roof under 5 years, stepping down to 40% or less past 15 years. On an older roof that can leave a five-figure gap.
- Actual cash value for roofs only. A policy can cover the house at replacement cost but pay the roof at depreciated value. Check the roof endorsement, not just the main form.
- Cosmetic damage exclusions. Dents on a metal roof that don't cause leaks may be excluded entirely.
Ask your agent which of these applies to you before the next storm season. It's easier to change coverage calmly than to discover it after the adjuster's visit.
How to read the adjuster's estimate
The estimate is usually produced in a standard estimating program and runs to several pages. The lines that matter most:
- Replacement cost value (RCV): what the insurer thinks the full job costs.
- Depreciation: the amount held back until the work is done, on replacement-cost policies.
- Actual cash value (ACV): RCV minus depreciation, which is what the first check is based on.
- Deductible: subtracted from what's paid to you.
- Line items: squares of shingles, underlayment, flashing, vents, gutters, and any code-upgrade allowance.
Compare the line items with your roofer's quote. If the adjuster missed the decking, the drip edge or the second layer of shingles, your roofer can submit a supplement with photos. Supplements are routine and often approved.
Supplements, re-inspections and appraisal
If the first estimate is short, you have options before accepting it. A supplement is a request to add missed or underpriced items, usually submitted by the roofer with documentation. A re-inspection is a second adjuster visit, useful when the first was rushed after a large storm. If you and the insurer still disagree on the amount (not whether the damage is covered), most policies include an appraisal clause: you and the insurer each hire an appraiser, and an umpire resolves differences. For disputes about coverage itself, your state's insurance department can take complaints, and a public adjuster or attorney may be worth consulting on a large claim.
Working out the financing number
The amount you may need to finance is the gap between the roofer's price and what insurance pays, plus timing. On a $16,000 replacement with a $14,500 RCV, $3,200 depreciation and a $2,500 deductible, the first check is $8,800. You owe the roofer $7,200 until the depreciation is released on completion, and $4,000 permanently (the deductible plus $1,500 the estimate didn't cover). Financing $4,000 at an illustrative 11.99% over 36 months is about $133 a month. Our guide to roof financing after hail damage walks through this step by step, and the roof financing page compares the options for the gap.
Check your inbox
Thank you for visiting AL Elite Financing. We've emailed the worksheet to . You can also download it now:
Download the PDFDidn't get the email? Check spam, or use the download button above.
Frequently asked questions
Does homeowners insurance cover a new roof?
It covers replacement when sudden damage from a covered peril (hail, wind, falling objects) requires it. It doesn't cover a roof that simply wore out. Your deductible and depreciation reduce what you receive.
Will my insurance pay for the whole roof?
Rarely in full. You pay the deductible, may lose depreciation on an ACV policy or until the work is done on an RCV policy, and pay for upgrades the adjuster didn't approve. That gap is what homeowners finance.
Can I finance my roof deductible?
Yes, through a legitimate lender. You cannot have the contractor waive it; that's fraud in many states and prohibited for AL Elite partner contractors.
Should I file a claim for minor roof damage?
Not always. If the repair costs less than your deductible, or only slightly more, filing may not pay and can affect your claims history. Get a roofer's assessment first and ask your agent how a claim would affect your renewal.
Will my insurance pay for a full roof replacement or just a repair?
It depends on the extent of damage and your policy. Insurers often repair isolated damage and replace when damage is widespread or matching materials aren't available. Some states have matching rules that affect this.
What is recoverable depreciation on a roof claim?
On a replacement-cost policy, the insurer holds back depreciation from the first payment and releases it after the roof is completed and invoiced, usually within a deadline set by the policy. Miss the deadline and it may not be paid.
Sources and further reading
Primary sources we rely on for this page. Program rules change, so check the source before you rely on a figure.
